Rabbi Jacobs - 1874
Rabbi F. Schauer - 1874 - 1878
Rabbi Pollak - 1878 - 1879
Rabbi Duschner - 1879 - 1881
Rabbi David Davidson - 1881 - 1885
Rabbi L. Freudenthal - 1885 - 1889
Rabbi Ignatius Mueller - 1889 - 1894
Rabbi Seymour Bottigheimer - 1894 - 1898
Rabbi S. H. Sonnenschein - 1898 - 1905
Rabbi Eugene Mannheimer - 1905 - 1943
      Rabbi Emeritus - 1943 - 1945
Rabbi Louis J. Cashdan,
      Associate - 1942 - 1943
      Rabbi - 1943 - 1945
Rabbi Martin M. Weitz - 1945 - 1948
Rabbi Bernard H. Lavine - 1949 - 1954
Rabbi Edward Zerin - 1954 - 1967
Rabbi Jay Goldberg - 1967 - 1983
Rabbi Steven M. Fink - 1983 - 1999
Rabbi Steven L. Mills - 2000 - 2002
Rabbi David J. Kaufman 2003 -